Irish High Court introduces two new practice directions designed to streamline clinical... Irish High Court introduces two new practice directions designed to streamline clinical...

Irish High Court introduces two new practice directions designed to streamline clinical...

The aim of the new procedure is to ensure cases are properly pleaded before a trial date is assigned and to facilitate the earlier resolution of...
Does the face fit? Does the face fit?

Does the face fit?

Experts are advised, if possible, to avoid expressing opinions on the basis of possibility. The usually applicable stand of proof is the civil...
Not a bridge too far – dental negligence Not a bridge too far – dental negligence

Not a bridge too far – dental negligence

The detail of this case is of relevance to dental experts and attention is drawn to the clarity and particularity with which Professor Harding set out...
Pacemaker PTSD? Pacemaker PTSD?

Pacemaker PTSD?

This is primarily a case for cardiologists, cardiac nurses and anaesthetists with a learning point for psychiatric experts. Viewed from outside the...
Podcast Episode 11: AI and the Expert Witness Podcast Episode 11: AI and the Expert Witness

Podcast Episode 11: AI and the Expert Witness

In the 11th episode of the Expert Matters Podcast, we take a look at how AI is being used by Expert Witnesses. We discuss general developments related...
EWI publishes new Guidance on Expert Discussions and Joint Statements EWI publishes new Guidance on Expert Discussions and Joint Statements

EWI publishes new Guidance on Expert Discussions and Joint Statements

We have just refreshed our guidance on ‘Expert Discussions and Joint Statements' in the EWI Knowledge Hub...
Postponement of the Extended Fixed Recoverable Costs Stocktake and Uprating of Fixed Cost... Postponement of the Extended Fixed Recoverable Costs Stocktake and Uprating of Fixed Cost...

Postponement of the Extended Fixed Recoverable Costs Stocktake and Uprating of Fixed Cost...

The Civil Procedure Rule Committee (‘Committee) decided, provisionally, to postpone the extended Fixed Recoverable Cost (‘FRC’)...
A Day in the Life of an Aerial Imagery Expert A Day in the Life of an Aerial Imagery Expert

A Day in the Life of an Aerial Imagery Expert

Chris Cox is a professional heritage consultant, specialist interpreter of aerial imagery and Lidar data, and an Expert Witness. She is the...
Podcast Episode 10: Equal Representation for Expert Witnesses Podcast Episode 10: Equal Representation for Expert Witnesses

Podcast Episode 10: Equal Representation for Expert Witnesses

In Episode 10 of the Expert Matters Podcast we celebrate International Women's Day. Women are appointed or testify in only 9% of disputes...
A Day in the Life of an Accountancy Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Accountancy Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Accountancy Expert Witness

Heather Rogers is an accountant, tax practitioner and Expert Witness. Most of her cases involve director disputes or professional negligence where...
Podcast Episode 9: Becoming an Expert Witness Podcast Episode 9: Becoming an Expert Witness

Podcast Episode 9: Becoming an Expert Witness

In the 9th episode of the Expert Matters Podcast, we look at how to become an Expert Witnesss. If you think expert witness work might be for you,...
A Day in the Life of an Emergency Medicine Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Emergency Medicine Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Emergency Medicine Expert Witness

Colin Holburn is an EWI fellow, governor and founding member. A consultant in accident and emergency medicine, he has been practising as an Expert...

Check out our Case Updates and Member Magazine

Looking for more news relevant to the Expert Witness community? Why not check out our database of cases relevant to Expert Evidence or the latest and previous editions of our member magazine, Expert Matters.

News

Clicking on one of the topics below will display news items relevant to that topic. You can also use the search bar below to identify news items.

A day in the life of a Surgeon
Priya Vaidya 3931

A day in the life of a Surgeon

byPriya Vaidya

Abeezar SarelaI have been a consultant surgeon, working in Leeds, since 2003. Each day in the life of a surgeon can be quite different. I will set out here a brief overview of the work-pattern of a surgeon in the UK, drawing on some of my own experiences.

 

A surgeon’s job does centre around the operating theatre (a popular scene of excitement in the media!); yet, in fact, it has various facets. Most surgeons in the UK will work in an NHS hospital. A surgeon’s NHS job, like that of a consultant in any specialty, is governed by a contract, and surgeons will work according to defined job plans. A job plan sets out the number of contracted programmed activities (PAs) and the type of activity that is to be delivered in each PA (or fraction thereof). A PA is a unit of time, and each PA represents 4 work-hours. A full-time NHS job plan has at least 10 PAs (40 hours) per week; a job plan of 9 PAs, or less, is a part-time job.

 

The PAs in a NHS job plan are typically split between direct clinical care (DCC; for example, operations, out-patient clinics and ward rounds) and supporting professional activities (SPA; continuing professional development, governance meetings, research, teaching and training). Some surgeons will have PAs allocated to additional NHS responsibilities (managerial roles, such as clinical lead or clinical director) or to external duties (roles in a Royal College, professional society or other external bodies). For the average surgeon, the job plan will have about 7.5 PAs of DCC and 2.5 PAs of SPA (although, of course, there can be significant variations). This usually translates in to spending only about 1½ days per week in the operation theatre; contrary to some popular myths of surgical lifestyle!

 

Notably, the DCC PAs are usually divided between elective or planned activities and emergency or on-call duties (typically involving out-of-hours and night-time work). For emergency work, a PA constitutes 3 hours (as opposed to 4 hours for elective work). Also, an elective working day is not necessarily limited to 8 hours: in some cases, one or two days of the week could extend to 10-12 hours. As a result of the combination of emergency work and longer-than-usual elective-working days, a 40-hour week does not usually translate into a surgeon being at his NHS hospital for all 5 weekdays. For most surgeons, a 10 PA job plan will be delivered in about 3½ days per week. It is important to be aware of these limits of a surgeon’s NHS contractual obligations in the context of clinical negligence litigation: an individual consultant simply cannot be expected to deliver continuous, hands-on clinical care.

 

The NHS consultant contract permits work outside the NHS, provided that such outside work is conducted in time that is not included in the NHS job plan. Many surgeons will work in private hospitals, in addition to their NHS job. As explained earlier, a 10 PA job-plan usually allows for 1½ weekdays to be free of NHS work. Consultants can do private practice (or anything else that they might choose to do) during periods that are not time-tabled in their NHS job plan (although, the private practice sessions have to be specifically stated in the NHS job plan). Some consultants will also work in the evenings, after completing their NHS duties; and others might choose to work on Saturdays, too. A surgeon with a full-time NHS job-plan and a well-developed private practice can, in this way, have a busy week: in some cases, up to 60 working-hours per week.

 

In the context of negligence litigation, it is important to note that a surgeon’s private practice will almost invariably mirror her or his NHS practice. If a surgeon undertakes an operation, which he does not do in the NHS, in the private sector, then the circumstances require close scrutiny. It is also noteworthy that the vast majority of private hospitals in the UK will simply not match the infrastructure or facilities of the local NHS hospital; and so, if complications develop, then private patients will often be transferred to the NHS hospital. It can be debated whether it is fair for the NHS to be obliged to support and subsidize privately-funded treatment by covering for complications; but, such, at least presently, is the reality.

 

Apart from private clinical practice, some surgeons (such as myself) will also have a medico-legal practice, that is, expert witness work. As with private practice, the medico-legal practice has to be conducted outside the NHS job plan. I have now been doing expert witness work for over 10 years, and I deal with a variety of clinical negligence cases within my specialty of upper gastrointestinal surgery. Bariatric (weight loss) surgery cases constitute a large proportion of my instructions; followed by cases pertaining to gallbladder, hernia, acid reflux, cancer (oesophagus and stomach) and emergency surgery. Since upper gastrointestinal surgery is a relatively small specialty, it becomes important to remain alert to conflicts of interest because close relations can develop over time with several colleagues. In the wake of recent judgments that have sharply rebuked experts for overlooking conflicting interests, I would recommend all experts, but particularly those whose professions are not large, to be watchful.

 

The combination of full-time NHS work, private work and medico-legal work can lead to high-pressured and conflicting demands on time: careful diary planning and work-life balancing are essential. ‘Burn-out’ can be a real problem for surgeons, and some will actively seek out leisure activities; yet, for many others, surgery remains the only passion. A mentor once said to me: ‘Surgery is neither an occupation nor a profession; it is a way of life’. To appreciate the distinctiveness of surgery from other medical specialties, consider that surgery involves the critical element of a craft—doing something with one’s hands—over and above the science and art of all branches of medicine. It is this craft that makes surgeons passionate about what they do; and it is also this craft that make it so difficult—nigh impossible—to opine on negligence in the performance of an operation. Two surgeons may write the same narrative of an operation, yet the difference of skill in the execution might be that between a master and a new apprentice.

In conclusion, a day in the life of a surgeon is highly demanding, yet varied and immensely satisfying. For myself, I could not imagine another way of life.

 

 

Abeezar I Sarela MBBS MS MSc MD PhD (Law) FRCS

Consultant Surgeon, The Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust

a.sarela@leeds.ac.uk

 

 

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.